Boot on the Other Foot: Putin Scuttles to Pyongyang as Desperation Grows

In April 1950, Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin gave his blessing to North Korean leader Kim Il-Sung to invade his southern neighbour. On the 25th June, Kim’s forces flooded across the 38th Parallel, beginning the Korean War. Having calculated that the United States and its allies would be too weary and disinterested to fight another Asian war, Stalin was surprised when a UN Security Council resolution (passed during the Soviet boycott) prompted an international response. When a ceasefire was declared in July 1953, some 3 million people lay dead, mostly civilians. No territorial changes had occurred, and no peace treaty was signed.

Source: ARSOF History

Like much of the early Cold War, Stalin and the Soviets played a key role in orchestrating events, even if they did not commit ground troops to the war in Korea. Instead, they encouraged the involvement of Mao Zedong’s People’s Liberation Army (PLA), itself battered after years of civil war. Mao was happy to sacrifice Chinese troops in support of his communist overlord, the Sino-Soviet split still being more than a decade away.

There was more than a hint of irony this week when Vladimir Putin travelled to Pyongyang to meet the current North Korean dictator Kim Jong-Un. Having not visited the pariah state since the early days of his presidency in 2000, Putin would surely not have done so now had it not been for his war in Ukraine and Russia’s increasingly isolated international position. Signing a pact with Kim that will ‘protect us both from aggression’, Putin’s visit is a sign of desperation and weakness. Joseph Stalin never went to Pyongyang, nor Beijing for that matter. People came to him, in his intimidating Kremlin lair. Despite Putin voicing hopes that his next meeting with Kim will be in Moscow, the North Korean leader will hardly feel compelled to comply.

Dictator bromance: Kim and Putin meet in Pyongyang. Source: CBS News

Exactly what has been agreed and promised between Putin and Kim will remain a closely guarded secret. Yet, it appears clear that Pyongyang is selling the Russians millions of artillery shells for use in Ukraine, perhaps in return for sophisticated nuclear submarine and missile technology. After their meeting in Vladivostok last September, there has been evidence that North Korean munitions are being used in the Ukraine war. Kim will exact a high price for this precious offering of war materiel, which he knows Putin is in desperate need of. Whilst it might not be in Moscow’s interest to have an increasingly powerful nuclear dictatorship on its border, Putin seems willing to do almost anything to ensure the signature play of his rule succeeds.

At the start of this year, Kim made a significant change to North Korea’s historical position re: the South. Whilst his father, Kim Jong-Il, and grandfather, Kim Il-Sung, had always vowed to unify Korea under communist rule, Kim junior has now declared South Korea its ‘principal enemy’ and abandoned the policy of unification. Recent incursions by North Korean troops across the demilitarized zone (DMZ) into the South have followed other provocative acts such as shelling South Korean waters and sending bags of human waste attached to ballons over the border.

A North Korean ‘waste balloon’ lands in a South Korea field. Source: DW

With North Korea continuing its unrelenting pursuit of nuclear build-up at the expense of its population’s well-being, the potential for a conflagration on the Korean Peninsula grows. Like Putin, Kim appears to realise his own mortality. There is perhaps nothing so dangerous as a dictator with nothing to lose, with both leaders having demonstrated their disregard for human life, friend or foe.

Hope rests in China. Although Xi Jinping has shown himself to be a revisionist leader with grand ambitions for regional and global Chinese supremacy, Beijing has always feared the destabilising presence of North Korea. Traditionally Pyongyang’s staunchest ally, China has typically been able to exert its influence to rein the Kims in when needed. Russia’s reliance on China for material support means that Putin would had to have consulted Xi before travelling to North Korea. Again, the boot is on the other foot compared to the Cold War. It is Moscow that must heed Beijing’s call, not vice versa.

Kim Il-Sung speaks in front of a portrait of Joseph Stalin. Source: Reddit

Whether Xi can soothe the malign intentions of his foreign underlings remains to be seen. He has displayed a ruthlessness comparable to Stalin in purging his domestic enemies. Now he must show similar strength in controlling troublesome allies, for the sake of China and the wider world.

Kim Comes Bearing Arms: Putin Rolls Out Red Carpet in Sign of Desperation

In April 1950 Kim Il-sung, the leader of North Korea, travelled by armoured train to Moscow to meet Joseph Stalin. Kim’s visit was to request military support for his impending invasion of South Korea from the Soviet dictator. Stalin agreed to send Pyongyang experienced World War Two military advisors, in addition to huge shipments of weapons and supplies. It followed a similar visit by Kim in March 1949, in which he pleaded for economic, technical and cultural assistance from the Soviets in his bid to build a flourishing communist society.

Kim Il-sung with Stalin. Source: LinkedIn

Having seemingly been convinced that the USA would not intervene in a war on the Korean Peninsula, Stalin had purportedly given Kim his blessing for the planned invasion at the start of 1950. Having had the seal of approval from the leader of the communist world, and backed by promises of weapons, Kim authorised the attack against his southern neighbours in June 1950.

The Korean War lasted for three years, embroiled not only the USA but also communist China, resulted in upwards of 2 million combatant casualties and perhaps 3 million civilian deaths. The Korean Peninsula remained divided between diametrically opposed states, who have not signed a peace treaty formally ending the war more than 70 years after an armistice was declared.

A US Air Force fighter pursues a Soviet MiG-15 during the Korean War. Source: National Museum of the United States Air Force

Fast-forward to 2023 and another North Korean leader, Kim Il-sung’s grandson Kim Jong-un, is planning his own trip to Russia in his armoured train. He will be granted an audience by Stalin’s successor, a man with similarly brutal and megalomaniacal tendencies, Vladimir Putin. Only this time the younger Kim will not be coming cap-in-hand asking for favours. Instead, he will likely be looking to finalise the sale of North Korean arms to Russia as Putin continues to wage his war against neighbouring Ukraine.

The extent and quality of North Korea’s weapons inventory is unknown. Yet, given that the country spends a disproportionate amount of its GDP on its military, at the expense of its starving, impoverished people, there is clearly a deal to be done with Moscow. Indeed, American sources suggest that Russian Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu begged Kim for weapons when he visited North Korea in July.

Kim shows off his missile collection to Sergei Shoigu. Source: BBC News

It would be inconceivable to think of previous Russian rulers asking for material support from North Korea. The Hermit Kingdom maintains very few bilateral ties given its isolationist tendencies, relies heavily on China for its survival and sees wild policy swings based on the whims of its leaders. A far from dependable ally, it is surely a sign of Putin’s desperation that he is calling Kim to town.

Last year Pyongyang recognised the illegal breakaway republics of Luhansk and Donetsk, before offering to send Russia 100,000 of its own troops to fight in the Donbas. Even Stalin refused to commit Soviet personnel to the frontlines in Korea in 1950.

Whilst Russia has maintained relations with North Korea since its founding in 1948, and the two countries share a short international border, the Kremlin has traditionally been wary of bolstering the Kim regime too much. Pyongyang’s nuclear sabre-rattling understandably concerns its giant neighbour and Russia has sided with the other great powers at the UN Security Council in a bid to slow the pace of North Korea’s nuclear development. That is unlikely to happen now, with Putin himself threatening to use nuclear weapons in Ukraine and Kim likely to extract every concession he can from any arms deal with Russia.

Kim met Putin in Vladivostok in 2019. Source: Sky News

What price Kim might squeeze from President Putin is a worrying, and unknowable, prospect. It is hard to imagine Joseph Stalin plummeting to such desperate depths, unthinkable that he might transfer advanced weapons technology to the Kim regime. But Putin might and he might soon. His depravity knows no bounds, his obsession with bringing Ukraine to heel seemingly untameable. When Kim Jong-un sees the red carpet unfurled in front of his armoured train, he will be taking a famous step in his country’s short and eclectic history.