California Burning: the Sad Reality of a Dry State

California has a lot of fires; it’s a pretty dry state. The increasing frequency of devastating blazes such as those currently raging to the north of Los Angeles is leading to unsurpassed human and economic loss.

Climate change proponents are quick to identify California’s prolonged droughts and wildfires as direct evidence that they are right. They may have an argument. But the destruction and fatalities caused by natural disasters across the world today are just as much about population growth and poor planning as they are about environmental factors, not to mention things beyond human control.

Prior to this week’s Camp Fire, which has so far resulted in at least 42 fatalities, the deadliest inferno in California’s history started at Griffith Park, Los Angeles in October 1933.

Scarred hillsides after the Griffith Park fire

A particularly barren summer had led to an excess of dry brush in the park, which gangs of workers from the Reconstruction Finance Corporation were hired to clear. On the 3rd October a small fire broke out in the park and quickly spread, with the inexperienced workers press-ganged into acting as emergency firemen.

Poorly planned backfires and inadequate firebreaks effectively trapped dozens of men in a swirling torrent of flame that was worsened by strong winds. Despite being brought under control relatively quickly by the emergency services, the Griffith Park inferno had claimed at least 29 lives.

Strong winds are currently hampering rescue efforts in California. No matter what the firefighting technology, the federal aid granted and the pre-emptive mitigation measures, a stiff breeze will exacerbate catastrophe.

The bodies were laid in a row on a concrete floor under a huge canvas shroud. Most were so badly burned that they could not be identified, except by their belongings, which were kept in an old apple crate.

As in 1933, macabre tales are being told today, with people found burnt to cinders in their cars or trapped in the rubble of their incinerated homes. When nature ‘wins’ the consequences are never pretty.

A body is recovered after the Griffith Park fire

It is unfortunate that the California fires are being used for political point-scoring and ‘I told you so’ jibes when all that should have been considered from the outset was a unified and comprehensive response to an inordinately difficult situation. Repercussions and recrimination can wait.

These things happen – as pointedly obvious as it seems to say – and the exact circumstances of such a disaster will never be the same and can never be predicted. A dose of realism is required; we are not all-conquering and we will never know the future.

Advertisements

Author: Stefan Lang

An interested observer of current affairs, researcher and writer

2 thoughts on “California Burning: the Sad Reality of a Dry State”

  1. “They may have an argument.” (Regarding climate change “proponents,” which itself seems like an oddly pejorative term to use). This is like saying that those who claim the Civil War had something to do with slavery “may have an argument,” or that those odd historians who link the Great Depression to overextension of credit “may have an argument.”

    Please, be very, very careful of statements like this. Minimizing the link between climate change and our recent wildfire events does great violence to the historical interpretation of these events, because it divorces it from the most important thing you need to make sense of history: context. Those who deny the proven scientific and historical reality of climate change are seeking to erase the enormous agency of climate change in our recent (and not-so-recent) history, just as they seek to eradicate it from discussion of current policy choices. Most of our recent history, from the Syrian Civil War to the European refugee crisis, Brexit, Trump and economic protectionism, is deeply rooted in climate change. To make an offhanded statement that it *might* (or might not be) a relevant factor to consider strikes me as very odd.

    1. Thanks for the response – not sure that the links to the other events you mention are appropriate but certainly understand the sentiment re: climate change. As ever, causal factors are invariably multitudinous. Just as climate change created the conditions that allowed Genghis Khan to prosper…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s